Tuesday, 28 September 2010

MoD group speakers’ notes


The following are Dougie Brownlies speakers notes from this mornings members meeting at Norcross.

Firstly, I want to thank the branch for inviting me here today and to all the members here and across the country for coming to these meetings and participating in and supporting our campaign.

As has happened previously, our union is totally dedicated to seeking the input and views of members in all the campaigns that we run. In little over a week, we managed to set over fifty MoD all member meetings up and down the country. In the MoD group we are totally committed to supporting the national campaign, but we will also link that into what we are doing in our department.

Since the coalition government has been in place, it seems to be attack after attack on public sector workers. The government’s motto and unfortunately now a catchphrase is that, “we are all in this together”.

You will see and hear pithy comments from the likes of David Cameron who stated just after he took office, “I believe deeply in public service” or new defence secretary Liam Fox who said last month “Our greatest asset is our people”. These laudable words are not however matched by the actions so far of the ConDem coalition government.

Whether it is the pay freeze, the threat of tens of thousands of job cuts, attacks on our pensions or the further pressure on our compensation payments we do not have far to go to find our next fight. “There is no alternative to pain” - this is the deafening drumbeat of the government.

But there is an alternative, and I’ll detail today what our union believes that alternative should be.

However before I speak about the alternatives our union is putting forward, I want to quickly touch on a couple of subjects that are frequently raised at all member meetings such as these – PCS working together with other unions and the media coverage of ours and other trade union’s campaigning.

I’ll start with where we are with other unions. In the MoD, our main sister union is Prospect and it is welcoming to come here today and tell you that at MoD group level we have started discussions with Prospect on how we can jointly campaign against cuts in our department.

These talks have started positively as both sides recognise that it would be reckless to campaign separately, especially when there will be no division as to where job cuts will fall. It is quite clear that job cuts will be across the board and will affect the full spectrum of workers across the Ministry of Defence.

Similarly at a national level, where we have sometimes struggled to get a united front, PCS and Unison have now pledged to forge a powerful alliance to fight back against the coalition government's cuts to public sector jobs and services. The unions are joining forces to campaign, co-ordinate and, where possible, take action in unity and support of each other.

Working together we can build an effective fighting machine to combat the cuts and protect vital jobs and services. At the launch of this alliance PCS general secretary Mark Serwotka said: "The millionaires in David Cameron's cabinet insist that we are 'all in this together'. But low-paid public sector workers and other vulnerable members of our society do not share this view when they can see the government's plans seek to punish them for the mistakes of bankers and financial speculators. Our alliance with UNISON is a crucial first step towards building the kind of united opposition that will be needed to oppose the government's spending cuts that will tear communities apart and destroy the public services we all rely on.”

It is not just Unison that we are looking to jointly campaign with; we are looking to build similar alliances with other public sector unions such as Unite and the GMB. Dependent on how the TUC vote in September, this looks like leading to a nationwide Spring 2011 demonstration against the cuts.

It was similar nationwide demonstrations in the early 90’s, organised and supported by the trade unions that saw the back of the poll tax and finished Thatcher. If seven million plus trade union members in the United Kingdom mobilise in a similar way it could have a repeat effect on the twin toffs coalition government.

Moving onto the media, I want to start by giving an example of the media work we do, and how it is picked up and used or in most cases not used by the media.

The quote I used earlier from Liam Fox – Our greatest asset is our people – came when he spoke to the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors on Friday August 13th. The contents of the speech were widely leaked to the media the night before, but needless to say, our union was not privy to the contents of the speech.

The first we heard about it was on breakfast TV and radio and we immediately started to put together briefings and a press release to get our point across. Our union has a full time media officer and alongside two GEC members he worked tirelessly all day getting our briefing together and then out to the media.

Lo and behold we got offered an interview for the BBC six o’clock prime time news. Hugh Lanning, deputy general secretary rushed across London to do the interview that lasted about 20 minutes.

Dr Fox’s speech was the lead item on the news and they did show part of Hugh’s interview – 8 seconds!!!

The result of 3 people working flat out all day and Hugh rushing about London was 8 seconds air time.

I think that example gives some idea of the kind of thing we are up against in this country. Our campaigning work does get plenty of coverage in local or regional papers and on regional TV and radio, but mainstream national TV and the vast majority of the written national press deliberately choose not to give us air time or column inches.

It is no coincidence that many of the newspapers in this country are owned and run by right wing tycoons or conglomerates and it should be remembered that they will never support our (or any other) trade union, regardless of how good our arguments are.


To sum up on the media, we will strive to get our stories heard and our campaigns publicised, but if you do not see it in your morning paper, please remember it is the choice of the editorial of your favoured newspaper rather than a lack of effort on behalf of our union.

Media coverage brings me onto everybody’s next favourite topic – our elected members of parliament who all seem to love a quote or two and their pictures in the paper. I’m being a bit flippant here, whilst there are undoubtedly some like that, the vast majority are in Westminster for the correct reasons – to represent their constituents.

Whilst we may have to accept that media coverage of our campaigning is limited, the opposite can be said about campaigning with our MP’s.

After the expenses debacle, the May 2010 intake of MP’s saw the highest amount of new entry MP’s for a generation, and whilst the majority of them will have party loyalties, the hope is that they will not simply blindly vote as per the party whips instructions, but will listen to their constituents, listen to the arguments and then make an informed decision.

Our union has launched the use of e-actions via the PCS website. This can ask MP’s to sign early day motions that are PCS sponsored, but can also be used to write to MP’s on specific subjects.

One such subject is a PCS MoD drop-in briefing that is going to be held on Wednesday 13th October between 12.30pm and 2.30pm. I’m going to talk in a minute about the alternatives to the cuts our union is putting forward, but before I do I want to spend a bit of time urging you to contact your local MP and ask them to attend this drop-in briefing.

As you will be aware, we are in the midst of the party conference season, and the first week back at Westminster for MP’s after the party conference season will be the week of the drop in briefing.

As it is on a Wednesday afternoon, it will also be immediately after Prime Minister’s questions so not only will the House of Commons be full, it will be full of MP’s hopefully with renewed vigour to make a difference to society – well that is what they all say they become politicians for!!

Seriously, though we have a prime time slot just a week short of the SDSR announcement. There is a chance that, if enough MP’s attend the drop in briefing then act upon the information we give them, then many of the worst scenarios that could happen may be averted.

As I said, the e-motion is on the website, just go to ‘where I work’ then click on Ministry of Defence and it is on the right hand side of the page. Complete this simple form and it will be sent directly to your MP.

One thing I would ask that you do is to keep us informed where you have lobbied your MP, especially when he or she says they will attend. After the drop in briefing we will report back on which MP’s did attend and what actions they promised to take.

However the drop in briefing is just one strand to our campaigning. I’ll talk firstly about what we are doing nationally and the ‘There is an alternative’ campaign.

Our first proposal is ‘tax justice’. At a time when this coalition government is attacking benefit fraud that is estimated at £1 billion a year, each year, more than £120 billion of tax goes uncollected, evaded or avoided by large companies and wealthy individuals. By just collecting the tax that is rightfully ours we could avoid public service cuts.

Of course benefit fraud should be eradicated, but should our priority be sending snoopers with binoculars to council estates to criminalize single mothers cleaning offices on the side to feed and clothe her children, or investigating tax havens in places like the Cayman Islands where the rich of this country hide their money to avoid or evade paying their fair share of tax to support our country.

A 'Robin Hood tax' on financial speculation could also raise an additional 400 billion dollars globally. The banks that we bailed out are again now advising their wealthy individuals or corporations on how to avoid tax liabilities. We bailed them out and instead of paying us back, within months they go back to their massive bonuses, lavish lifestyles and ensuring they look after their own. It certainly does not appear that they are included in the ‘we are all in this together’ message.

As well as bringing in a fairer tax system, we believe the government should be creating jobs to boost employment and tax revenue, not cutting them. Cuts will damage the economy. By cutting public sector jobs, unemployment will increase – increasing the costs to the government – and lower consumer spending will mean fewer transactions and less tax revenue through VAT. It will also result in the private sector cutting back because there is less demand.

Alongside the national campaign, the MoD group has launched its own campaign entitled ‘Defence Cuts Cost’.

In our department, we have seen civilian numbers slashed by approximately 22% in just over six years whilst, since the last defence spending review in 1998, military posts have actually increased by 4.7%.

Our union fully understands and agrees that there is an indisputable requirement for military personnel to do some non-military roles. However, not all military-held posts demand military expertise. We are arguing not for civilian job losses, but that the department actually increases the use of civilian workers in non-deployable posts to ensure frontline support is maintained.

Until you look at the facts, increasing civilian numbers may sound like a foolish idea and I have no doubt that is how it will be reflected in the right wing media. However our union will use the facts to prove that we can give the same if not better support to the front line but at a much cheaper cost. In many cases, military personnel driving desks cost twice as much as a comparable civilian. As an example for every wing commander that is replaced with a B2 (a full grade higher in equivalency) the MoD saves approximately £20k per annum in wages alone.

If we really are all in this together, then Liam Fox and his government must accept that where defence outputs can still be delivered, but delivered at a fraction of the cost by civilians, then it is a decision that must be taken.

If you have been to union meetings like this over the years, you will be aware that our union has asked members to provide us with details of waste across the MoD. We still badly need examples of MoD waste as we will use these with MP’s and ministers to show them where savings could be made. To give a taster, here are just four typical examples provided by members –

· Privatisation - “EDS made $10 million worth of errors in 2008/09 most of which was written off. Because the penalty clauses had been triggered, under Treasury rules the agency could spend the virtual monies that had not been collected – essentially doubling the impact on the public purse.”
· Consultants – “While working as the IT Manager within an IPT member overheard two consultants talking about how one was buying his sixth house from the money he was making out of contracting for the MoD. While civil servants on wages that don’t allow them to get one mortgage let alone six it sickened me that the MoD is paying others with no loyalty high payments to have work undertaken”.
· IT – “On DII, Atlas are charging £1,500 for moving one printer port – a matter of 20 to 30 foot of wiring.”
· T&S – “Since the MoD mandated the use of HRG to source travel & accommodation, the MoD is charged approx 10% commission on every booking whether booked over the phone or through the contractor’s site. HRG don’t always have the same availability as a carrier’s site and even when they do the MoD still fork out the 10% commission over and above the costs. One example is when going through HRG to visit MoD Head quarters it was set to cost £245, after calling local booking agent was able to cut the price to £65.50.”

Our union is sure this is the tip of the iceberg as regards waste in our department – if you have any more examples, please let your local PCS representative know, or alternatively email wastereport@pcs.org.uk.

For many months now, our union has been trying to ascertain what cuts will be proposed in the MoD. Unfortunately, this has been a very difficult exercise, as it appears that it is the National Security Council, chaired by the Prime Minister and not the MoD who will be making the final decisions. Until we get definitive proposals, all of the purported cuts are at present pure speculation.

That said, there is little doubt that whatever is proposed will be deep and wide ranging. We understand the National Security Council is meeting on 17th and 28th September ahead of 20th October comprehensive spending review announcements. The final decision on where the Trident budget will sit is also expected by end of September.

Our union is quite clear on what the priorities must be for the MoD in the months and years ahead –

1. We believe that we need more not less civilian staff to ensure the front line is properly supported.
2. We will demonstrate how much waste, such as the examples just cited, there is in the MoD and that this should be eradicated before a single job cut is contemplated.
3. We will explain how cuts kill communities e.g. if Lossiemouth and Kinloss were closed this would add 16% onto an already high level of unemployment in the area.
4. We will give examples of how the privatisation agenda is flawed e.g. Although DERA was performing well, in 2003 the government decided to privatise part of it, and a Private–Public partnership called “QinetiQ” was created, after which the 10 senior civil servants responsible for taking the company into the private sector saw their total personal investment of £540,000 transformed into £107 million. The PCS General Secretary called this “obscene”, but the UK Minister for Defence Procurement described it as “a model for future privatisations.”

These are just a few quick examples of waste in our department. I want to talk now for a couple of minutes about the other issues affecting members at present, namely pay, pensions and the compensation scheme.


Starting with pay, the pay freeze is a direct attack on civil servants as we face a double whammy of not getting a pay rise and also not having pay progression – pay progression that is still available widely across other parts of the public and private sector such as the NHS.

Our union totally condemns the arbitrary £21,000 pay freeze level, especially as this figure is also to include any location and skills allowances and also part time staff whose full time salary is over £21,000.

Along with our sister public sector unions we will be campaigning for a fair and decent living wage for all members of staff. In the MoD group, our pay sub committee will be meeting shortly to start drafting our 2011 pay claim following on from the imposed 3 year pay offer. We will be looking to address those areas where we are still in dispute with the department, identify further areas of inequality that remain within the pay system that need addressing and deal with the proposed pay freeze.

Average civil service pay remains over £2,000 less than in the private sector, with basic civil service pay 3.5% below inflation since 2007. Freezing the pay of millions of public sector workers will actually worsen the deficit, as workers will spend less, therefore affecting retail jobs and thus deepening the recession.

Public sector pay freezes are again part of the coalition ‘we are all in this together’ agenda, but before any pay freeze is blindly accepted I’d ask members to remember the following – less than a year after our taxes bailed out the banks, the Royal Bank Of Scotland paid bonanza bonuses of more than £1 million to more than 100 bankers on top of their already bloated salaries. Therefore, those who advise their and the Cabinet millionaire’s friends how to avoid paying tax are once again raking it in whilst public sector workers on £21,000 are told to take a pay freeze for a minimum of two years.

On pensions, apart from some generic comments from the ConDem coalition about ensuring public sector pensions are affordable, we have not as yet seen definitive proposals to slash our pension entitlements, as the issue is currently the subject of a review by former Defence Secretary John Hutton.

However I’m sure nobody will be putting their heads in the sand regarding threats to our pensions. If and when they do come, I’d urge members to remember the following – the TUC Pensions Watch survey, which examined the pension arrangements of 329 directors from 102 of Britain's biggest companies, showed the value of director's pension pots jumped £400,000 in the last year to £3.8m, providing an average annual retirement income of £227,726. Remind yourself of this when again you are told ‘we are all in this together’.

The most recent industrial action we have had to take in our union was in defence of our compensation scheme. Allied to our legal action, these three superbly supported days of action ensured that the previous government’s proposals were defeated.

However we now have a ConDem government determined to punish our union for fighting for our members, whether that be through industrial or legal action. This government’s use of a monies bill – the Superannuation Bill – is simply an abuse of parliamentary power to eradicate the terms and conditions of civil servants.

Although it was welcome that Labour had a three line whip and all Labour MP’s voted against the recent 2nd hearing of the bill – it is interesting to note that the Labour party is easier to work with now they are in opposition – our union is now having to mount a further legal challenge and will seek a further judicial review if necessary. It is welcome that other civil service unions are currently supporting this.

Our union has also written to the speaker of the House of Commons asking that he reconsider whether this is in fact a money bill and that he withdraws it. From research our union has done and also advice from the PCS parliamentary group, it is hoped that this will be successful.

I want to conclude today by saying simply that this is going to be the fight of our lives. It is vital we all do everything we can to persuade the government to think again. Cutting jobs and services will plunge millions of people into poverty and cause enormous damage to our living conditions and the service to the front line in all departments, but particularly to our front line in the Ministry of Defence. Our message is that the government cannot cut its way out of the recession.

When ministers talk about progressive cuts, and tell us 'we're all in it together', we must expose this for the nonsense that it is. Let's be clear about this: cuts always hit the poorest, most vulnerable, most disadvantaged people.


Cutting 600,000 public sector jobs will also lead to 700,000 private sector job losses. We know this, because the document telling George Osborne this came from his own Office for Budget Responsibility and was leaked to the Guardian at the end of June.

We should be creating jobs, not forcing thousands of workers onto benefits. Our union urges every PCS member to get involved and to encourage your colleagues to do the same.

Both the national and the MoD group campaign need your full support. Unchallenged at least 1 in 4 MoD jobs, if not more will go by 2015. Sites, communities and families will be ripped apart if we do not win this battle.

It may sound clichéd, but it never has been more important to stand together and put a united front up against these Dickensian proposals.

This united front may and probably will include industrial action. We have already seen London tube strikes against job cuts, fire-fighters are currently balloting over modernisation plans (always a euphemism for cuts and job losses) and BBC employees have called strikes later this month over attempts to get back their pension entitlements.

Industrial action will and always will be the last resort. Nobody takes industrial action lightly. Our members are at the heart of our communities, and especially in the MoD, our members are extremely loyal and care passionately about the integrity and the quality of the services they provide. But we are entitled to be clear. The ConDem government is pursuing a political programme but faced with attacks on jobs, pay or pensions; if our members take a democratic decision for industrial action, they will have the support of our union and the wider trade union movement.


As I said earlier, both at national and MoD group level, the various unions are starting to work together to fight against these cuts. You can help too – we all know colleagues who are not yet members of our union – speak to them today, tell them the challenges we face, tell them what our union is doing and ask them to join.

I’m going to finish now by recounting two stories in the news on Monday 13th September. Firstly it was opening day of TUC Congress with almost universal support for united action in the face of the most brutal cuts package since Thatcher. Buried away was the second story, possibly buried as somewhere, somebody within the political and right wing media classes does actually have a conscience.

It was reported that FTSE 100 executive bonuses are now close to pre-crisis levels with average bonuses for directors of FTSE 100 firms amounting to 100% of their basic salary, rising to 140% in the top 30 public companies.

I’ll let you work out the link between the 21 millionaires in the cabinet and this story. In my opinion, this is undoubtedly a government of the heartless for the benefit of the selfish, but together, united I honestly believe the trade union movement can and will make a difference.

There is an alternative; our union is making the case for that alternative both at national and MoD level.

Thanks very much for listening to me today; I’m more than happy to answer any questions you have.

A letter from Eric... gets a response.


An open letter to Eric Ollernshaw OBE MP

Dear Eric

Thank you for your letter of 20th September regarding the coalition governments plans to destroy the Civil Service Compensation Scheme (CSCS).

I am glad to have your assurance that the Government values the professionalism and contribution that civil servants make to deliver excellent public services. However, I think it is a shame that you do not demonstrate such qualities in the factual accuracy of your response.

Firstly, whilst the nations debt is, as you say, running at £155 billion, it is not immediately an answer to start attacking the long established terms and conditions of your employees. As your esteemed parliamentary and party colleague Andrew Robathan, the Minister for Veterans stated when visiting us recently, it is as wrong to attack OUR terms and conditions, as it was wrong for the attacks on the T&Cs of Members of Parliament, and he understood from this the ‘pain’ such an injustice has and would continue to cause. That said, there are other areas that could be focused upon; for one the £120 billion a year lost in uncollected, avoided or evaded taxes that you seemingly fail to recognise.

Secondly, you point out that PCS was the only union to stand against the previous Governments proposed changes (in point of fact there were at least two other unions that rejected the changes), and that the other unions such as GMB, Prospect, Unite, the Prison Officers Association and FDA all agreed the changes. However, it should be understood that FDA members were the authors of the proposals, and so they can hardly count, but even if one does include them, together these other bodies represent at most only 20% of the civil servants affected by the proposals, whereas PCS represents 80% of all civil servants. PCS members rightly rejected the proposals and took industrial action against them. Our actions were later vindicated in the courts when the proposed changes to the scheme were deemed to be illegal. It is your Government that is now changing a law to make an illegal action retrospectively legal. That is nothing short of shameful.

Third, you state that the CSCS is too expensive, with it in some cases being worth up to six and two thirds years of salary! I am sorry, but this is entirely inaccurate. The only part of the a civil servants T&C’s that refers to 6 and 2/3rds years is in some cases where Agreed Early Retirement (AER) is offered on enhanced terms, but then this refers not to years of salary but to years added to service for purposes of calculating the retirement pension. It requires 40 years to obtain a ‘full’ CS pension. However, in the event of an enhanced AER, someone aged 53 might be 7 years or more shy of qualifying for a full pension. However, the added years are offered as an incentive but only in some cases. To conflate a term that applies in exceptional cases of retirement with conditions applying to mass redundancies is very careless. To then use that as a justification for reducing general conditions is nothing short of misleading.

If you truly believe that it is ‘entirely fair and necessary to seek reform of’ the CSCS, I would hope as your constituent that you would at least first get your facts right.

Thursday, 16 September 2010

The Superannuation bill

A new e-action has been live on the PCS website for over a week now. This encourages MPs to attend a drop-in briefing on 12 October and also participate supportively in the debate of the remaining stages of the bill in parliament. Can I encourage as many members and reps to send this e-action to their MP as possible - http://e-activist.com/ea-campaign/clientcampaign.do?ea.client.id=103&ea.campaign.id=5067.

Your letter will look something like this:


Dear Mr Ollerenshaw,

I’m writing to ask you to attend a drop-in briefing with representatives from my union, the Public and Commercial Services Union (PCS) on Tuesday 12 October about the superannuation bill, which is due to reach its report stage and third reading in October.
The bill seeks to cap redundancy payments for civil and public servants at a maximum of 12
months’ salary for a compulsory redundancy and 15 months’ salary for a voluntary redundancy.

This means that in the event of redundancy, my colleagues and I working hard in constituencies across the country will receive a vastly reduced compensation payment. Some of us could even lose as much as 50% of the payments that we’ve accrued during our time working for the government, which at a time of financial instability is a real concern to me and my colleagues.

The Superannuation bill, that the government hopes will be ruled as a money bill by the Speaker at third reading, to allow for a speedier legislative process, will return to the Commons in October for its remaining stages. The bill that the government has introduced will severely impact me and my colleagues in the event of a redundancy situation. With the looming comprehensive spending review I am fearful that spending cuts will be made which could jeopardise my future employment. Therefore redundancy payments being changed in such an aggressive manner at this time is obviously a
huge concern to me.

My colleagues and I are anxious that introducing this legislation as a money bill will not allow time for the requisite scrutiny and parliamentary debate and would ask you to participate supportively in the debate raising our concerns and oppose the bill.

This is a real concern to me and many of my colleagues and therefore as my elected
representative I would ask you to:
• Attend the drop-in briefing being held on 12 October between 12.30pm – 2pm in room W3 in the
House of Commons
• participate supportively in the forthcoming debates that will take place in October; and
• urgently request a meeting with the Cabinet Office Minister the Rt Hon Francis Maude MP

I understand the severity of the economic situation, however my colleagues and I should not be penalised. We do however believe that we should have our contracts honoured, especially as many of us have dedicated our lives to public service and don’t receive the generous salaries or pensions often quoted – in fact an average civil or public servant receives only £22,850 per year and a pension of £4,200 per year – hardly the gold-plated sums the media and many politicians state.

For more information please contact PCS on campaigns@pcs.org.uk or 020 7801 2820.
Yours sincerely


The public bill committee met this week and took evidence from civil servants, PCS members and staff and also from the CCSU. The remaining stages of the bill have provisionally been scheduled for 13 October in parliament and PCS are intending to also hold a drop-in briefing for peers the week before toensure they are aware of our concerns before it comes to them.


Tuesday, 14 September 2010

The UK's armed forces

Royal Navy
Personnel: 34,230
Reservists: 420
Equipment: 12 Submarines; 2 Aircraft carriers; 6 Destroyers; 17 Frigates; 7 Main amphibious; 23 Patrol; 18 Auxiliary; 13 Sea Harrier and 119 Helicopters

Army
Personnel: 100,290
Reservists: 37,260
Equipment: 386 Main battle tanks; 3,768 Other armoured vehicles; 877 Artillery and 299 Helicopters

Royal Air Force
Personnel: 39,750
Reservists: 140
Equipment: 287 Combat capable aircraft (137 Tornado, 58 Eurofighter, 34 Reconnaissance aircraft); 131 Helicopters (40 Chinooks, 28 Merlin and 34 Puma)

Savings of 20 per cent are demanded from the MoD's £38bn budget over the next four years. However, the cost of Trident and two new aircraft carriers needs to be added to this list.

Where will the axe fall?

Wednesday, 8 September 2010

MPs vote to shaft civil servants

Members of Parliament have last night voted in favour of placing a cap on "unaffordable and unsustainable" redundancy pay in the Civil Service.


MPs voted the Superannuation Bill, which would cap redundancy pay at one year's salary or 15 months for voluntary redundancies, through at its second reading by 326 votes to 244. Attempts to implement the previous Labour administration's reform proposals instead by means of an amendment were defeated by 329 votes to 240.

Opening the debate, Cabinet Office Minister Francis Maude urged civil service unions to agree new redundancy terms and make the Bill ''a dead letter'' before it becomes law. But he warned that a single trade union would not be allowed to stand in the way of reforming the current arrangements. Mr Maude said the current scheme made it ''prohibitively expensive'' to get rid of highly-paid, long-serving staff, meaning lower-paid workers were disproportionately hit if job cuts were needed.

We believe these changes are purely to make it possible to on the cheap, dispose of thousands upon thousands of civil servants.

Amazingly Shadow Cabinet Office minister Tessa Jowell agreed that the current redundancy scheme provided ''overly generous and disproportionate benefits for some very highly-paid people''!

However, she at least argued that reform ought to provide more "protection for the lowest-paid". She added that the Bill was being used ''very deliberately to force the trade unions into compliance'', which was a ''very unusual use of parliamentary procedure''.

We believe we will see more of this during this ConDem'd government.

Wednesday, 25 August 2010

Poor families robbed by Chancelor

George Osborne's budget is described as 'clearly regressive' by respected fiscal thinktank Institue for Fiscal Studies.

Britain's leading independent tax experts today flatly rejected the coalition government's claims to have shielded poor families from five years of austerity when they described George Osborne's emergency budget as "clearly regressive".

In a direct challenge to Treasury claims that the package of spending cuts and tax increases announced in June was fair, the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) said in a report that welfare cuts meant working families on the lowest incomes – particularly those with children – were the biggest losers.

The IFS said it had always been sceptical about Osborne's claim that the budget was "progressive" but added that this instant judgment had been reinforced by a study of proposed changes to housing benefit, disability allowances and tax credits due to come in between now and 2015.

Passing judgment that is likely to make uncomfortable reading for the Liberal Democrats, the IFS concluded: "Once all of the benefit cuts are considered, the tax and benefit changes announced in the emergency budget are clearly regressive as, on average, they hit the poorest households more than those in the upper middle of the income distribution in cash, let alone percentage, terms."

Nick Clegg, the Lib Dem leader, has argued that the budget represented "progressive austerity" by sparing the poorest families from the brunt of the attack on the UK's record peacetime deficit.

Yet all the while the rich get richer, and pay no taxes, and the bankers get their bonuses. Same old Tories it seems.

Monday, 23 August 2010

Defence Secretary Attacks.... a Game?

Thats right. At a time when the MoD is facing perhaps our biggest expenditure cuts in history and amidst the Strategic Defence Spending Review, Dr Liam Fox has taken time out from his undoubtedly busy schedule to attack the content of a video game as being "thoroughly un-British".

That the game itself, Medal Of Honor has yet to be released seems to matter not. The game centres of the 2001 invasion of Afghanistan in which players 'go in' with the ISAF forces.

Dr Fox says he is "disgusted" and that "it is shocking that someone would think it acceptable to recreate the acts of the Taliban against British soldiers."

Unfortunately for Dr Fox, the game does not allow for that which he claims. Whilst it is true that in the multi-player game teams can form from the US or opposing Taliban sides, no British troops are included within any of the scenarios.

Hopefully Dr Fox spends more time researching real defence issues and expenditure than he did before attacking this game. Frankly one phone call or a cursory glance at a gaming magazine would have demonstrated the futility of charging up that particular hill!

That said, he has got form for this sort of thing. You might remember Dr Fox extolling the virtues of the Duke of York before the last election. Not Prince Andrew of course, but the Duke who increased the standing army from 50k to half a million to face Napoleon, with the help of 30 odd civil servants! He forgot to mention however, that the housing, feeding, clothing, arming and paying of that massive army was contained within its regimental structures and duplicated endlessly and at vast expense to all the services. It is for most of those functions that the MoD Civil Service side exists. We pay, feed, clothe, arm and house the services at a fraction of the cost of the uniformed equivalent. Furthermore, civillians free up much needed personnel for active service, to march them up hills, and then march them down again.

Thursday, 19 August 2010

Nick agrees with us?

Following on from our campaign to expose tax avoidance amongst the super rich, most recently being Sir Philip Green, the Deputy Prime Minister and ConDem'd politician Nick Clegg has finally come around to our way of thinking... while his boss is on holiday!

Liberal Democrat MPs have called for the tax affairs of the government's efficiency advisor Philip Green to be investigated after Nick Clegg pledged to crack down on tax avoidance.

The appointment of the Topshop billionaire last week to head a review of the government's drive to cut public spending was controversial with tax experts and trade unions, who accuse him of avoiding a personal tax bill of nearly £300m.

Green dismissed the criticism as irrelevant, but his role has come under scrutiny again after Clegg said yesterday that clamping down on tax avoidance was on the coalition government's agenda.

Speaking at an event to promote the government's efforts to increase social mobility, the deputy prime minister said: "We are looking at the case for an anti-avoidance rule to ensure that wealthy individuals pay their fair share of tax."

Clegg's comments prompted Liberal Democrat MPs to demand that Green's tax affairs be investigated.

Wednesday, 18 August 2010

11% error rate on JPA

The Ministry of Defence (MoD) plans to conduct a "major data cleansing exercise" to improve its payroll software, the Joint Personnel Administration system (JPA) following "significant" errors in the payment of allowances and expenses to service personnel.

In March 2009, a Defence Select Committee report found thousands of members of the UK armed forces received incorrect salary payments because of a "catastrophic" computerised payroll system. Initiatives were put in place to improve the £245m system, including the correction of data in service personnel records, extended checking of expense claims and improvements in management information.

While the MoD has reduced the level of likely error from £145m last year, 11% of transactions tested by MoD staff still contained an error in allowances and expenses payments, "There remains significant further work to be done to ensure that a robust control environment is established and that processes are sound," said the report.

The JPA was implemented by IT supplier EDS, now HP, which has been linked to several problematic public sector IT projects, such as the Child Support Agency system.

Tuesday, 17 August 2010

Taking the P, out of PFI!

If an example of how far we have gone in our reckless mad dash towards privitisation of the whole public estate, the image presented here seems to sum it up.

A gents toilet in a privately maintained government building has been awaiting repair of a urinal for the best part of three weeks.

Doubtless the pressure on the the other two has caused a failure of the second urinal...

... and will no doubt hasten the demise of the third.

It seems a fitting reminder about how the push for 'private profit' has impacted upon us all.

Soon we will have barely a pot to Pfi in.

Vince Cable's dig at Sir Philip Green's tax status

Mythical financial genius Vince Cable (against public spending cuts before the election, in favour of Tory spending policies after...) has launched a thinly veiled attack on billionaire Sir Philip Green's tax arrangements.

In a swipe at the new Whitehall adviser on public sector waste, the Business Secretary said: 'I remain of the general view that British businesspeople should pay their taxes in Britain.'

Sir Philip Green you will remember famously has his business billions held by his wifey and kiddies in Monaco... so he doesn't have to pay any tax.

Five years ago his company paid his missus and the sprogs a dividend of £1.2 billion pounds. Thats one thosand and two hundred million pounds by the way. This was tax free. This effectively deprived the nation of around £450 million pounds.

The sad part is that this man is just the tip of the iceberg. There are thousands like him who avoid paying tax and do so by cosying up to whichever party looks like getting power. In this case a Labour supporter before 2010, a Conservative supporter since reading the writing on the wall!

Is it any wonder Cameron targets benefit cheats but lets the real scroungers get off for free!? Not only that, he gives him a responsibility in government.

Monday, 16 August 2010

Friday, 13 August 2010

Fox outlines backroom cuts to make MoD 'leaner'

But where will SPVA sit, if at all?

The Defence Secretary set out plans today to reorganise the MoD into three pillars: policy and strategy, the Armed Forces, and procurement and estates.

Frankly, it seems we sit somewhere outside of the MoD according to the plan. We wonder where? DWP? The Private Sector?

Answers on a postcard to....

'Call Me Dave' calls billionaire to help with cuts.

Billionaire retailer and mega tax dodger Sir Philip Green is to advise David Cameron on cutting Government spending. The Monaco resident has been recruited to lead a review scrutinising the past three years in order to identify waste.
His business empire is mostly owned in the name of his wife Tina because she lives in the tax haven of Monaco, where Sir Philip spends his weekends. The couple moved there in 1998.

This arrangement is thought to have saved the couple tens of millions of pounds in tax over the years. He famously paid his family a £1.2billion dividend in 2005. Lady Tina was able to receive the dividend tax-free because she is an official resident of Monaco.

Asked about his wife's tax status he replied: 'My wife's not a tax exile - my family do not live in the United Kingdom, it's somewhat different.'

And questioned over whether Britain would benefit from owners of British businesses paying all their taxes in the country, Sir Philip added: 'We do pay all our tax in Britain, I think we have paid over the last five years some £300-400 million in taxes on profits that have been made on our company." (Note he spins this answer, as the tax is paid by the company on its profits.)

'I'm a UK taxpayer, I work here every week, we employ 45,000 people in the UK and we have got a £500 million payroll.' (Again more spin. Like most of the other multi-millionaires and billionaires he is a 'UK taxpayer ' in a very limited sense...)

MoD JPA system at risk of cyberattacks

The accounting officer for the Ministry of Defence has said that data losses and weaknesses in the department's information infrastructure has left it vulnerable to virtual attacks.

In the MoD's resource accounts for 2009-2010, Bill Jeffrey says that although the department is working to improve awareness of potential online attacks, the risks to its cybersecurity is still a worry.

The department's Joint Personnel Administration (JPA) system, which provides services including payroll functions and centralised records of service, is also singled out as a problem area by the accounting officer. He says that despite a number of steps being taken to improve the system, "there are still concerns over the quality of elements of the underlying data set".

"This has meant that we still have a number of unresolved issues to do with payments and visibility of data on the numbers of army reservists. As part of plans to address these, the army will be undertaking a major data cleansing exercise," Jeffrey concludes.

NHS facing £65bn 'mortgage' bill for PFI

The NHS in England faces a total bill of £65bn for new hospitals built under the private finance initiative (PFI), six times more than the buildings cost.



Figures obtained by the BBC show that some NHS trusts are spending more than 10 percent of their turnover on the annual ''mortgage'' repayments.

Under PFI, private companies win contracts to build and maintain new hospitals and mental health units and the NHS pays off the ''mortgage'' over around 30 years.

The 103 schemes were valued at a total of £11.3bn when they were built.

But when rising fees and additional costs such as maintenance, cleaning and catering are taken into account, the NHS will have to pay back £65.1bn over the lifetime of the schemes. Some contracts are reportedly so restrictive that trusts are forced to pay hundreds of pounds just to get half a dozen pictures put up.

According to the data, the NHS currently pays back a total of £1.25bn each year but this figure is expected to increase until 2030 when it will hit £2.3bn, the BBC reported.
The final payment will not be made until 2048.


What is even more obscene is that we are paying twice for this, because we have loaned companies in the PFI contracts the money needed to undertake these capital projects at extremely preferential rates. They then not only charge us for what is effectively a self financed 'mortgage', but they also charge us interest on our own money!


You could make it up, but then you wouldn't believe it.

Thursday, 12 August 2010

'Call Me Dave' has his priorities...

Writing, rather approriately in the Sun today, on the subject of welfare reform and benefit fraud, the Prime Minister makes the case against himself in a single, revealing, dog-whistling sentence:

That's why benefit fraud is the first and the deepest cut we will make.

Benefit fraud?? Which costs the country £1.5bn a year (or less than 1 per cent of the £155bn budget deficit)?

Not tax evasion or avoidance by the rich, which costs around £25bn?*
Not the £1.6bn lost to the taxpayer in errors and maladministration of the benefits system?
Not the £5bn rail subsidy, which helps fund the multi-million-pound bonuses of fatcat rail bosses?
Not the £2.5bn being wasted by the Ministry of Defence every year?
Not the £4bn prisons budget, which, as the Justice Secretary admits, doesn't cut crime?
Not the £4bn spent annually on a bloody, pointless and catastrophically self-defeating war in Afghanistan?

Nope, cutting benefit fraud. That's Cameron's main mission. I think it speaks volumes about his priorities and his preferences. So much for the veneer of "progressive conservatism".
Mehdi Hasan, New Statesman, 12/08/2010

* It should be noted that Mehdi quotes from a particular set of data that does not include for instance, an even greater slice of tax being lost to the 1000 or so billionaires and multi- millionaires who last year increased their wealth by £77 billion and on which they paid virtually no tax at all... well, perhqaps something like £10 million, but it is hard to tell. Most of them have done deals with the HMRC to pay one-off peppercorn taxes of £10,000 at the beginning of the year to avoid the revenue the problem of actually counting up how much they should really pay.
If one was to look at it coldly, and apply 45% to last years increased wealth alone, that would account for £35 billion pounds for the revenue. That would cover MoD, Afghanistan, Prisons, Network Rail and any welfare cheating!

Who will pay BP spill Bill?

Not only the wildlife and the environment suffer from the BP oil spill. Local residents, fishermaen and the holiday trade have all suffered.

So how about BP? Of course they will suffer too, won't they?

Well, actually... not much. Apart from any fines imposed by the US government for negligence, BP will actually transfer about a third of all costs dealing with the cleanup and compensating businesses directly onto the taxpayers of the UK and the US, deducting all these costs from their taxable profits. This is estimated to be around $10 billion... very nearly the amount 'Call Me Dave' claims benefit cheats are overclaiming by.

What a coincidence!

Tuesday, 10 August 2010

"Call Me Dave" targets benefit cheats

An "uncompromising" crackdown on benefit cheats will be unveiled in the autumn, "Call Me Dave" Cameron pledged today. The Prime Minister said reducing the £5.2 billion* annual cost of fraud and error would be the "first and deepest" cut in public spending?

"Welfare and tax credit fraud and error costs the taxpayer £5.2 billion a year. That's the cost of more than 200 secondary schools or over 150,000 nurses. It's absolutely outrageous and we can not stand for it."

Well, this is all very outrageous, but for all the wrong reasons. How much more outrageous is the fact that £95 to £120 billion a year is lost to the country in avoided and defrauded tax revenue, nearly all of that from the top percentile of earners and corporations. That is 20 times the the very worst estimate of benefit and tax credit fraud. Thats the cost of more than 3 million nurses and 4000 secondary schools. Perhaps 'Call Me Dave' has his priorities wrong? We wonder why?

*Interestingly, fraud and error was estimated at the maximum as being around £700 million just a few months ago. Now, either benefit cheats have found 800% more ways under this Condem government to cheat the system, or something is very wrong, yet again, with 'Call Me Daves' figures.

Monday, 9 August 2010

More private sector job cuts on way

The government's hope that private sector employers will create enough jobs to make up for public sector cuts have been dealt another blow with news that a growing number of businesses are planning to cut staff.

Just under third of employers – 32% – across the state and private sectors said they expected to make some workers redundant during the next three months. It was a rise on the 29% recorded in the previous quarter, according to a survey run jointly by the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development and accountants KPMG.

Redundancies were more likely in the public sector, where 36% of employers planned to shed jobs, reflecting cuts for government departments and councils announced by the new chancellor George Osborne in June. But the outlook in the private sector was not much brighter with 30% of employers planning staff cuts, up from 24% three months earlier.

HP: Hany Panky?

Hewlett-Packard Co CEO Mark Hurd resigned on Friday after an investigation found that he had falsified expense reports to conceal a "close personal relationship" with what HP claimed was "a female contractor."

We are not sure what HP contract for, as she turns out to be Jodie Fisher, a 50-year-old adult film actress and reality TV contestant who said on Sunday that she was “surprised and saddened” that Mark Hurd, 53, had lost his job following her allegations.

An HP probe cleared Mr Hurd, 53, of sexually harassing the actress but found he had submitted inaccurate expense reports to conceal a “personal relationship” with her. That she claims that they had not had an affair or intimate sexual relationship only deepens the mystery.

Perhaps the full story is somewhere on a missing data drive.

Friday, 6 August 2010

PCS Campaigns Update

As part of our campaign against the government’s planned cuts, we are calling on all members to help protect our public services. Cuts are neither necessary nor inevitable. In fact, we believe there is an alternative. If you are not a member, please consider joining us and being part of a democratic campaigning union, run by our members, for our members.

For more information on our campaigns, visit www.pcs.org.uk/campaigns. You can also join the PCS Facebook group at www.pcs.org.uk/facebook, and follow on Twitter, www.twitter.com/pcs_union.

Thank you for your invaluable support.

Civil Service Compensation Scheme

Support our campaign to defend the civil service compensation scheme by sending an email to your MP asking them to raise our concerns with Cabinet Office minister Francis Maude and participate in the debate in parliament on 7 September. The government has introduced new legislation that caps redundancy payments which will be debated in Parliament, make sure your MP knows how angry you are about there proposals: www.pcs.org.uk/cscseaction

Wednesday, 4 August 2010

Have the IEA gone bonkers?

The Institute for Economic Affairs has just released the following apparent admission of insanity!

"In a new research paper released today, the Institute of Economic Affairs argues the coalition's proposals on financial reform will do little to improve the quality of financial regulation in the UK.

The coalition is proposing to abolish the FSA and reallocate its functions between a series of new quangos and the Bank of England. Instead "Does Britain need a financial regulator?" (authored by Philip Booth and Terry Arthur) suggests the regulation of investment markets, financial products, insurance companies and other financial institutions, currently carried out by the FSA and the Pensions' Regulator, should be stopped and these sectors should instead be allowed to self-regulate within a framework of limited primary legislation."

Self-regulate? The bankers?? Have the guys and gals at the IEA been in a coma for the past two years? Or are they really the evidence-denying, bank-defending, free-market fanatics that this press release suggests?

How Bankers... Bank!

The commonly-held view that banks merely lend the deposits of their customers, and profit from the difference between the interest paid to depositors and the rate charged to borrowers is probably the most misunderstood aspect of money and banking today. Banks CREATE credit which is merely a book-keeping entry.

Yes, that is literally creating money “out of thin air”.

This is achieved through the practice of Fractional Reserve Banking. It is literally legalised fraud. UK Banks lend out between 33 and 60 TIMES the amount they hold on deposit.

That's not a misprint they “lend” out far and above what they actually have on deposit.97% of our money supply is created as interest-bearing debt. This debt is simply bank credit, created by private commercial banks for PRIVATE PROFITS. The remaining 3% of the money supply is cash. As bank notes and coins are created by the state, they are supplied debt-free. In fact, banks have to purchase cash from the Bank of England and the Royal Mint and pay the face value for them. The difference between the cost of producing cash and the face value is paid directly to the treasury. This profit is called Seigniorage. This money can be used for public services – without resorting to borrowing or taxation.The problem today is that only around 3% of our money is cash.

Whilst banks (nor anyone else) cannot counterfeit notes and coins, banks are legally allowed to CREATE ‘credit’. This means that ALL new bank “loans” are actually CREATED as a book-keeping entry only. Notice how most of us rarely need to convert that ‘bank credit’ into actual legal tender, or cash. (because of cheques, debit cards, bank to bank transfers etc). We’re merely passing around what is called ‘non-cash’ money.It’s because there is very little cash being used today. For you see, if 97% of our money is created as a debt by private companies, can you not see where the REAL source of the problem lies? Address this and the national debt can be paid off, booms and busts can be eliminated, and taxes can be slashed without reducing public services - all because the interest will no longer be payable.Think about it this way: Why does the nation have to borrow 97% of it's money supply from private companies? It doesn't.

For more information visit: BenDyson

Tuesday, 3 August 2010

Fixed retirement age to be axed: Updated


According to Workplace Law 30th July, the change to the law is unlkikely to affect private firms as, according to Tom Flanagan, an employment law expert at Pinsent Masons.

"An employer can still justify a mandatory retirement age and use justifications like wanting to balance the workforce and provide opportunities for younger employees," said Flanagan. "The Court of Appeal's ruling sets not that difficult a test, it is not particularly stringent."

Therefore the new law is much less than that previously bragged about by the coalition government and falls far short of that currently in the public sector as introduced under the previous government.

Previous article read: The coalition government is planning to scrap the default retirement age in the UK from October 2011. Under the proposal, employers would not be allowed to dismiss staff because they had reached the age of 65.

Activists, who have long campaigned against the rule, welcomed the proposal as a "victory" against ageism. Currently, an employer can force an employee to retire at the age of 65 without paying any financial compensation.

The only obligation on an employer is to hold a meeting with the member of staff to discuss plans at least six months before their 65th birthday. At the end of that meeting it is entirely at the discretion of the employer whether or not to terminate employment.

'Unresolved problems'

The government has launched the start of a consultation process about scrapping the rule.
Given that an employer must give six months' notice before forcing someone to retire on the grounds of age, it means the changes could be felt from 6 April next year. After that date, no new forced retirement notices could be issued.

The CBI business group criticised the speed of the proposed changes saying it left firms "with many unresolved problems". The government's timetable to scrap the default retirement age would give companies little time to prepare, it added.

However Rachel Krys of the Employers Forum on Age was delighted, saying it was "really unfair" that people had been forced out of jobs because of their age. "We have to stop these blunt discriminators," she added. The charity Age UK, which has led the campaign to end the default retirement age, welcomed the government's plan. Last year it challenged the rule in the High Court but was unsuccessful. "We've fought really hard to get government to do this," a spokesman said. "It is a massive win for hundreds of thousand of employees who are at risk of being forced out of their jobs."

Economic benefit

David Yeandle of the Engineering Employers Federation: "It will make it more difficult for workforce planning" Proposals to change the retirement law formed part of the government's Coalition Agreement, and was included in both parties' manifestos, but previously no deadline had been set. The government hopes the change will encourage people to work for longer, against a background of an ageing population. That could ease the strain on public finances as more people continue to pay tax, while at the same time claiming the state pension.
Activists have argued it could inject billions of pounds extra into the economy.
But some employers are worried it will complicate the job of managing a workforce and add to overall costs.

We would be interested in members views.

Veterans Welfare Service

In July, branch officers at the invitation of VWS management were able to visit the new Veterans Welfare Centres in Centurion, Imjin, Kentigern and in Kidderminster, and take part in meetings with all the VWS staff in SPVA. Many issues were raised and dealt with during these sessions. However, some issues such as continuing connectivity problems for IT persists and are being pursued.

One problem in particular that is of immediate interest to the visiting welfare managers is that of payment for travelling time. As some of you may know, since the economic crises, MoD like all of Whitehall have put tight restrictions on travel, overtime and travel time. There are though, exceptions to all rules as can be seen in the recently released 20100729 Control of Financial Commitments in CTLB:

"Travelling time

7. As for overtime (below), payment of travelling time will only be allowed if authorised explicitly in advance. HLB and SABU holders should delegate authority to do this as appropriate. In all cases, payment of travelling overtime should be kept to a minimum and scrutinised carefully by line managers, and Time Off In Lieu considered as an alternative wherever possible. However, payment for untaken annual leave will not be made where this results. "

On the basis of this instruction, the branch has written to Director of Veterans Services to request that authority should be extended to VWS management that allows discretion to pay travelling time to those welfare managers travelling on official business.

Greedy Bankers

HSBC posts six month profits of £7 billion pounds, an increase of 121% that is likely to be replicated by the other high street banks.

Meanwhile most small to medium sized business have struggled to get loans or maintain existing arrangements with the banks. Even the 'Boy' George Osborne says, "Every small and medium-sized company that I have visited in recent weeks has had some problem with their bank - either they have found it difficult to renew their overdraft or the bank demanded additional collateral, often someone's house." Read More Here

Lloyds and RBS, which received billions from the taxpayer to keep them afloat, are set to unveil profits of nearly £1billion between them. In total, Britain's five biggest banks are forecast to return half-yearly profits of £8.4billion. The extraordinary return to profit is also likely to lead to a return of the massive bonuses widely blamed for helping spark the credit crunch.

You might ask yourself, how do they make such big profits? Well, we are giving it to them. You see, the Bank of England borrows money from abroad at a fixed interest rate... something like 3.6% (thats what the fuss about our Triple AAA credit rating is about). Then they lend it to the banks at something like a 1.5% interest rate. The banks then lend to us at 5.5 to 19.5% interest and pocket the difference. The differential between the cost of borrowing for banks from BoE, and from banks to us, is the biggest in history. So we pay inflated interest rates to the bankers and then pay again through our taxes to fund the cheap money the BoE lends to them.

Then the bankers get huge bonuses, that we have paid for, and on which they generally pay the lower rate of Capital Gains Tax! Therefore we as the public are in an effective, lose, lose, lose, lose scenario. Ever feel cheated?

Addendum: On Monday nights Newsnight, financial experts actually argued that we cannot force banks to lend to help small to medium size business... but government could do more! You could not make it up.

Monday, 2 August 2010

NHS trusts bid to attract private patients

Elite NHS foundation trusts are gearing up to lure private patients from home and abroad as health budgets are squeezed – a decision made possible after health secretary Andrew Lansley said he would abolish the cap limiting the proportion of total income hospitals can earn from the paying sick, you can read more here.

This news brought this to mind the following:

"I warn you that you will have pain–when healing and relief depend upon payment.
I warn you that you will have ignorance–when talents are untended and wits are wasted, when learning is a privilege and not a right.
I warn you that you will have poverty–when pensions slip and benefits are whittled away by a government that won’t pay in an economy that can’t pay.
I warn you that you will be cold–when fuel charges are used as a tax system that the rich don’t notice and the poor can’t afford.
I warn you that you must not expect work–when many cannot spend, more will not be able to earn. When they don’t earn, they don’t spend. When they don’t spend, work dies.
I warn you not to go into the streets alone after dark or into the streets in large crowds of protest in the light.
I warn you that you will be quiet–when the curfew of fear and the gibbet of unemployment make you obedient.
I warn you that you will have defence of a sort–with a risk and at a price that passes all understanding.
I warn you that you will be home-bound–when fares and transport bills kill leisure and lock you up.
I warn you that you will borrow less–when credit, loans, mortgages and easy payments are refused to people on your melting income.

If Margaret Thatcher wins on Thursday–
- I warn you not to be ordinary
- I warn you not to be young
- I warn you not to fall ill
- I warn you not to get old."
Neil Kinnock, 1983

Thursday, 29 July 2010

'Boy' George Osborne: Trident costs to come from Defence budget

George Osborne delivered a rebuke to the defence secretary, Liam Fox, when he declared that the costs of Britain's new Trident nuclear deterrent will come from the main defence budget.

In a sign of the Tory's leadership's growing impatience with Fox, who has embarked on what Downing Street sources have dubbed as "freelance" missions, the chancellor said there could be no special accountancy exemptions for the defence budget.

Speaking to Bloomberg in New Delhi, Osborne said: "The Trident costs, I have made it absolutely clear, are part of the defence budget. All budgets have pressure. I don't think there's anything particularly unique about the ministry of defence. I have made it very clear that Trident renewal costs must be taken as part of the defence budget."

The chancellor's blunt remarks will be seen as something of a reprimand for Fox who complained recently that his department was being asked to pay the £20bn costs of replacing Trident. Fox believes that the costs of replacing Trident should come directly from the Treasury because Britain's continuous-at-sea defence is a matter of national security.
Read More Here

This will come as a blow to those who were optimistic in the fact that the MoD as a department was only being asked to find 20-25% savings over the coming years compared to 30-40% in most other departments. When Trident is factored in (£1 to £2 billion a year) and the suggestion that all the MoD's savings will come from non-service areas... it seems likely that MoD civil servants might well face real cuts of between 30 & 40% over the coming two or three years!

Wednesday, 28 July 2010

Civil servants 'treading water' with no job to do

- because it's too expensive to make them redundant! Read More Here


Mr Maude told the Public Administration Select Committee that current arrangements make it 'prohibitively expensive' to offer redundancy to some civil servants, leaving them 'in limbo'. 'In most departments there are people for whom there is no job,’ he said.

Francis Maude you will remember famously claimed almost £35,000 in two years for mortgage interest payments on a London flat when he owned a house just a few hundred yards away. He owned the house outright but in 2006 took out a £345,000 mortgage on the flat about one minute’s walk away. He then rented out the house and began claiming mortgage interest payments on the flat which is in a grade II listed building with a gym and 24-hour concierge.
Mr Maude also claimed, and was paid, £387.50 for the cost of moving his effects down the road from the house to the flat.

He claimed £18,112.50 in mortgage interest payments for the year 2006-07, £1,790 for council tax, £2,237 for a service charge and £820 for cleaning.

A further £9,801.78 was claimed for mortgage interest payments from April 1 to Aug 31, 2007.
The senior Tory MP then submitted a claim for the mortgage interest payments for the remainder of the 2007-08 financial year, which came to £13,070.96.

In a note to the House of Commons fees office he said he knew there was not enough left in his ACA account to cover the payments.

The fees office paid out £6,748.52, up to the maximum of his allowance.

The 55-year-old MP is independently wealthy. He was previously a managing director of Morgan Stanley, a director of Salomon Brothers and a non-executive director of Asda during the 1990s.

Tuesday, 27 July 2010

Quangos a go-go

David Cameron vowed in opposition to rein in Britain's quango state in an attack on a bloated public sector.

His threatened cull of taxpayer-funded organisations yesterday became reality for thousands of workers as the Health Secretary, Andrew Lansley, announced that half of the "arms-length bodies" run by his department were to be abolished.

The move to scrap such quangos as the Health Protection Agency provoked anger among nurses and doctors' organisations, which warned that public wellbeing would suffer as a result.

To date, the coalition Government has axed at least 80 quangos and warned many others that they faced mergers or deep cuts.

All of these will result in job losses across the country and could have huge impacts upon public health, welfare and culture.

ABOLISHED SO FAR

ARTS
*UK Film Council
*Museums, Libraries and Archives Council
*Advisory Council on Libraries
*Legal Deposit Advisory Panel
*Advisory Committee on Historic Wreck S ites

HEALTH
*Health Protection Agency (HPA)
*National Patient Safety Agency (NPSA)
*National Treatment Agency for Substance Misuse
*Alcohol Education and Research Council
*Appointments Commission (CQC)
*Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (by end of this Parliament)
*Human Tissue Authority
*Council for Healthcare Regulatory Excellence (to be made a self-funding body by charging a levy on regulators)
*NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement

EDUCATION
*General Teaching Council
*Qualifications and Curriculum Development Agency
*British Educational Communications and Technology Agency (BECTA)

BUSINESS AND ECONOMY
*All eight regional Government Offices: South-West, South-East, East Midlands, West Midlands, East of England, North-West, Yorkshire & the Humber and North-East
*Eight out of the nine regional development agencies (the exception being London) and some of their local subsidiaries: Advantage West Midlands, East Midlands Development Agency, Yorkshire Forward, South-West Regional Development Agency, South-East England Development Agency, East of England Development Agency, North-West Regional Development Agency, One North-East
*Strategic Advisory Board for Intellectual Property policy (SABIP)
*SITPRO (Simplifying International Trade)
*Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment Advisory Body (WAB)
*British Shipbuilders Corporation
*UfI/Learndirect
*Learning & Skills Improvement Service
*Institute for Learning *Standards and Verification UK
*IiP UK
*Hearing Aid Council
*Investors in People UK

HOME OFFICE
*National Policing Improvement Agency

ENVIRONMENT
*Sustainable Development Commission (funding withdrawn)
*Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution
*Agricultural Wages Board, the 15 Agricultural Wages Committees, the 16 Agricultural Dwelling House Advisory Committees and the Committee on Agricultural Valuation
*Inland Waterways Advisory Council
*The Commons Commissioners
*Infrastructure Planning Commission
*Commission for Rural Communities

MERGED

ARTS AND SPORT
*UK Sport and Sport England
*National Lottery Commission with the Gambling Commission

UNDER THREAT

ARTS
*Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment, English Heritage, Heritage Lottery Fund, National Heritage Memorial Fund – could be merged
*Advisory Committee on National Historic Ships (declassified, functions transferred to another body)
*Theatres Trust (declassified, so can act as an independent statutory advisory body)
*Churches Conservation Trust (could be declassified, pending talks with the Church of England) *Visit England and Visit Britain (status, role and functions will change)
*Design Council (under review)

BUSINESS
*Local Better Regulation Office
*ACAS (Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service)
*Local Better Regulation Office
*Ofcom (in the short term it is losing its policy making power)
FOOD
*Food Standards Agency (its responsibilities have been much reduced)

ENVIRONMENT
*Carbon Trust (could be merged into new UK Green Investment Bank)
EDUCATION
*Partnership for Schools (school-building)
*Training and Development Agency (was facing the axe, but may now be spared)
SOCIETY
*Children's Commissioner for England – under review
*Equality and Human Rights Commission – has been accused of wastefulness by Home Secretary and faces further cuts

Auditors refuse to sign off MoD accounts

National Audit Office says 'systemic' problems mean defence ministry is unable to account for £6bn of equipment

The National Audit Office today refused to sign off the Ministry of Defence's annual accounts, for the fourth year in a row.


The spending watchdog said the MoD was unable to account properly for more than £6bn of equipment. The head of the audit office, Amyas Morse, said that despite efforts by the MoD to tackle the issue, there remained "systemic and deep-rooted" problems with its asset management system.

He said it had emerged that the problems were more extensive than previously thought as the work done to track down the equipment brought fresh difficulties to light.

The NAO found the MoD was unable to account for the whereabouts of £5.5bn of spares and other stocks, and £752m of military equipment, including firearms and 5,961 Bowman radios worth £184m.

"Despite action by the department to improve its asset management and accounting, the issues I have identified are systemic and deep-rooted," Mr Morse said. "The level of control exercised by the department is not yet sufficient to enable me to provide an opinion on a significant proportion of assets reported in the financial statements."

The MoD said that the issues raised by the NAO had no impact on the provision of essential equipment to frontline troops. "The National Audit Office has recognised that the MoD has improved procedures for inventory management and, by the end of March this year, had completed a full reconciliation of Bowman radios," a spokesman said. "We are continuing to work hard to improve our inventory management and ensure our accounting systems become compliant with financial reporting standards, but recognise that both issues will take time to be rectified."

DIY Police?

Cameron's answer to budget cuts: get public involved in 'DIY' policing

David Cameron's "big society in action" answer to police budget cuts has been revealed as a plan to appeal to the public to take part in "do-it-yourself" policing ‑ and perhaps even go on patrol with uniformed officers.

A radical police reform white paper published by the home secretary, Theresa May, says that she wants to explore new ideas including creating a reserve army of volunteers prepared to act as community crime fighters along similar lines to fire reservists who help staff some neighbourhood fire stations.

The idea for greater public involvement in policing emerged as the home secretary's Liberal Democrat coalition partners warned that the current state of her proposals to introduce directly-elected police and crime commissioners are in danger of giving a green light to "Judge Dredd populists".

Given that we are all also expected ("Call Me Dave" and Boy George Osborne" etal exempted of course) under the "big society in action" to volutarily cut the verges, clear the litter, run the schools, nurse the sick, care for the infirm... it does beg the question, when will we be able to find the time to do all this voluntary work?

Presumably when we are unemployed!

Saturday, 17 July 2010

The Gravy Train.

Civil servants find lucrative roles in private sector

The predicted explosion in the public services market will see a stream of top civil servants and managers being offered lucrative packages to join private outsourcing companies competing for government business.

Some of these will have been instrumental in drawing up government policy and providing advice to ministers. Many who have gone already have been accompanied by their ministerial bosses.

Ministers who have taken paid non-executive positions in the private health sector include Milburn, who became an adviser to Bridgepoint, a private equity firm specialising in healthcare investments. Patricia Hewitt, health secretary 2005-07, became an adviser to Cinven, a private hospitals group. And Lord Warner, a health minister 2003-2007, became chairman of the government sector advisory panel for Xansa, which provides business and accounting services to the NHS.

The former top civil servant Sir Bruce Liddington, once in charge of Labour's academy schools programme under Tony Blair left the Department for Education in January 2009 to become the £250,000-a-year director of E-Act, a social enterprise and registered charity which operates eight academy schools funded with £50m of public money. It has plans to develop five more academies. The one-time head teacher was accused earlier this year of enjoying a "culture of excess" after he claimed thousands of pounds for stays in luxury hotels and taxi hire to visit academies around the country. E-Act said Liddington repaid the money and denied he used limousines.

Friday, 16 July 2010

Remember the promises from 'Call Me' Dave?

Dave: "Let me say clearly to any pensioner... you are getting letters from Labour to say that we would cut the winter fuel allowance, free bus travel and free TV licence. These statements are simply lies, I don't use that word often, but I am today because they are lies." Press Conference, 23 March 2010

Dave: "We will keep the free TV licence, the winter fuel allowance, the free bus pass. Those leaflets you have been getting from Labour, the letters you have been getting from Labour are pure and simple lies." Leaders debate, 22 April 2010

In todays Mail, read the following:

"Now wait five more years to get your bus pass: Millions face means test to get free travel"

Thursday, 15 July 2010

Britain’s debt: The untold story

The true scale of Britain's national indebtedness was laid bare by the Office for National Statistics yesterday: almost £4 trillion, or £4,000bn, about four times higher than previously acknowledged.

It quantifies the burden that will be placed on future generations, and it is the ONS's first attempt to draw together the "off-balance-sheet" liabilities that have been accumulated by the state. The figures imply a huge "intergenerational transfer" – broadly in favour of today's "baby boomer" generation at the expense of younger people and future generations.

The debt primarily consists of the cost of public sector and state pensions, and of payments promised to private contractors under private finance initiatives. It far exceeds any of the figures so far published for the national debt, the largest current estimate for which is £903bn. That is projected to rise to £1.3trn by 2015.

If the current generation of taxpayers wanted to remove the higher bills facing their children and grandchildren, they would now be paying around 30 per cent more in tax.

The ONS data strengthens the Government's hand in its attempt to pull down state spending.

The ONS itemised the public sector's main liabilities as:

* Future payments for the state old age pension: £1.1trn to £1.4trn
* Unfunded public sector pensions for teachers, NHS staff and civil servants: £770bn to £1.2trn
* Payments under private finance initiative contracts: £200bn
* Contingent liabilities (eg bank deposit guarantees): £500bn
* Nuclear power plant decommissioning: £45bn
* Impact of financial sector interventions: £1trn to £1.5trn

Leaving aside the possibility of another financial meltdown that would leave the taxpayer with the liabilities of a substantial part of the banking system, the figures suggest that the realistic total liabilities of the public sector could be as much as £3.8trn (£3,800,000,000,000).

Read More Here

Tuesday, 13 July 2010

Civil Service Compensation Scheme

The coalition government has announced plans to introduce new legislation to cap redundancy payments for civil servants and

It is crucial that we continue to keep up the political pressure in the campaign. We are calling on all members and supporters to ask their local MPs to sign EDM 301 and to also ask the Cabinet Office Minister the Rt Hon Francis Maude MP to urgently enter into new negotiations on the CSCS.

Please email your MP and ask for their support in our campaign: www.pcs.org.uk/cscseaction