Wednesday, 16 March 2011

Save us from this Cut!

by Johann Hari, The Independent

The only job David Cameron ever had outside politics was as a PR man for a large corporation – and now he is using the skills he learnt then to launch an act of rebranding worthy of a panicked business desperate for brand decontamination.

The Prime Minister knows it's wildly unpopular to impose the biggest programme of cuts since the 1920s – especially when our national debt has actually been higher for 200 of the past 250 years. YouGov has found that 50 per cent of us think the cuts are too deep, 53 per cent think they are bad for the economy, and 63 per cent think they are unfair. But rather than listen to the people, Cameron has a different solution: rename the cuts. From now on, they are to be called "savings".

The Prime Minister is trying to impose this shift on the BBC, publicly lambasting them last week into altering their vocabulary. The excellent blog http://liberalconspiracy.org/ has documented the subsequent shift in their news reports. But this is a change from using a factual and neutral word to one that is in many cases literally inaccurate. Let's start with the word "cuts". It is not a pejorative. I have cut the amount of food I eat over the past year, and I'm proud of it. I have cut the amount of time I spend reading fiction, and I'm dismayed by it. The word neutrally and aptly describes both. It means simply "to reduce the size, extent or duration of". The word "savings" means something different – and they are not synonymous. Here are three obvious examples of cuts that are not savings.

Example one. The major HIV charities are warning that the Government's actions are leading to a big cut in the public money given to their projects to persuade high-risk people to be tested for HIV, and then carrying out the test quickly and for free. So the number who find out they are HIV-positive is going to fall. They will then be – as reams of research has demonstrated – considerably more likely to spread the disease. All the people they infect will then eventually require treatment. So the Government gets to keep the £50 for an HIV test and the £10,000 a year for somebody who persuades hundreds of people to take it, but then they have to spend £250,000 to treat each newly infected person over their lifetime. That's a cut – but it's not a saving.

Example two. Public investment in the arts is being cut by 27 per cent. To pluck one example, the Film Council was abolished, even though it funded a renaissance of British cinema, including the Oscars-smash The King's Speech. Independent studies found that for every £1 the Arts Council spends, it generates £2 more in tourism (these films are massive adverts for Britain), added employment, new tax revenues, and more. That's a cut – but it's not a saving.

Example three. Until Cameron, local authorities were required by law to make sure that when a young offender was released from custody, he was given a place to live. The reason is obvious: if a young person who has fallen into crime walks out of jail with no money and nowhere to go, they are virtually guaranteed to commit more crime. That means you or me getting mugged or burgled. Now the Government has abolished that responsibility. So they'll get to keep the £5,000 a year it would have cost to house them, and instead will spend the £78,000 a year it costs to process them through the criminal justice system. That's a cut – but it's not a saving.

If Cameron coaxes the BBC – and others – into rebranding these acts as "savings", he has coaxed them into a lie. George Orwell wrote: "Political language is designed to make lies sound truthful and murder respectable, and to give an appearance of solidity to pure wind. One cannot change this all in a moment, but one can at least... send some worn-out and useless phrase into the dustbin, where it belongs." The "saving" we need most is to save our language from being contaminated with this latest lie.

j.hari@independent.co.uk

Thursday, 10 March 2011

MoD Early Release Scheme


PCS Guidance

Our union intends to produce guidance for members on the application of the early release scheme, even though we remain opposed to its use and terms. Unfortunately, the department has been unable to answer a number of key questions, submitted by PCS, on the operation and terms of that scheme which materially affect that guidance.

We understand that a number of members genuinely wish to leave the department at this time, either because they have had enough or because they have personal circumstances which would be eased by leaving the MOD. Our objective is not to stop such members applying for the scheme; rather to negotiate the most advantageous terms for them to leave on. Members should therefore think carefully before accepting any offer of early release and ensure that they fully understand the consequences and implications of leaving the department under the current terms.

Our priority remains to retain jobs within the MOD, as demonstrated by our successful meeting with the Secretary of State for Defence in support of our Defence Cuts Cost campaign.

Selection Panels

We are aware that TLBs have been inviting PCS representatives to participate in the selection panels for the current departmental early release scheme.

PCS remains opposed to the early release scheme and will therefore not be assisting the department in its implementation. It would therefore be both inappropriate and unhelpful if PCS representatives were involved in any capacity in selection panels set up to administer the scheme.

TLB lead representatives should ensure that their HR Business Partners are aware that PCS will not be participating in ERS selection panels.


Chris Dando Group President
Bob Rollings Group Secretary

Pension reforms: Public sector workers to pay more and retire later

A government-commissioned report by Lord Hutton, the former Labour pensions secretary, proposes sweeping changes to state pensions that will mean nurses, doctors, teachers, local government and other public sector workers will have to pay more into their pension pots, retire later and many will receive less when they do.
All state employees in the UK will be affected, creating the first legal basis for simultaneous strike action across the unions, who have universally condemned the report.

The Guardian has revealed details of the first co-ordinated strikes, which are already being planned for June. Read more here.

You can view the PCS response here.

Why trust Osborne and Cameron? King doesn't seem to

Published in full the text of David Blanchflowers take on Mervyn King's contradiction of the ConDems financial strategy from todays New Statesman.

The Bank of England governor has directly contradicted the Chancellor's claim that the recession was all Labour's fault.

We may well look back at the first weekend of March 2011 as the point when the fortunes of Britain's coalition government changed. Over Saturday 5 and Sunday 6 March, we heard three speeches - from David Cameron, George Osborne and Iain Duncan Smith - that had nothing substantial to say and simply spread further economic disinformation and fear. There was also an awkward, off-stage, intervention by my old boss, the Bank of England governor, Mervyn King.

All in all, I get the sense that panic is setting in and that the economic mantra that the Conservative leadership has been trotting out since last year's election is being ignored. Evidence of this can be found in a YouGov poll, carried out on 3 and 4 March, in which the majority of respondents (56 per cent) thought the coalition was "handling the economy badly". Blaming the previous Labour government for all things bad on the economic front is no longer working.
In his speech at the Conservative spring shindig, Cameron declared war on the "enemies of enterprise". Upsetting six million public sector workers just as the austerity measures - read unemployment - hit probably isn't that smart. Earlier the same day, Duncan Smith told the conference that "it's not the absence of jobs that's the problem. It's the failure to match the unemployed to the jobs there are." Rubbish. There are five unemployed people chasing each recorded vacancy in Britain. Two years ago, the ratio was three to one. Duncan Smith appears not to understand that jobs for brain surgeons in Richmond aren't much use to an unemployed plumber in Rotherham.

The fear index

Meanwhile, Chancellor Osborne's speech - with its usual sarcastic, sneering tone - contained little to no economic analysis, but much political rhetoric. There were some weak pro­m­ises about creating enterprise zones, but if they were such a good idea, why didn't he announce them in his Budget of May 2010?

The rest of the speech was punctuated with the usual platitudes: "We are on a hard road to a better future"; "We have to be realistic about where we're coming from - and optimistic about where we're going"; "We faced up to the task in hand"; "Our world will become a freer and richer place. But in the short term it adds to the challenge." He went on: "We are on your side. It's people who create growth." Really? I thought it was kangaroos.

He once again repeated the dangerous lie that "our nation was on the brink of bankruptcy". It wasn't. A chief executive of a major FTSE 100 firm wouldn't use such language, because if he did there would be a run on the company share price. The same rule should apply to the Chancellor of the Exchequer. As I have noted before, consumer confidence has collapsed since the leaders of the coalition started talking the economy down.

An update on the decline in confidence was published earlier this month by the European Commission. It charts what respondents in a monthly survey think will happen to un­employment over the following 12 months. A bigger number means that a higher proportion expect unemployment to increase. It is plotted in the graph below, alongside the unemployment rate. The series increased from May 2010 and jumped sharply in February 2011, from 51 to 56, the highest level since June 2009. There is fear. Consumers are expecting unemployment to rise, even though it has stayed pretty steady. This lack of confidence is likely to lead to lower consumer spending, which in turn will lower growth.

So far, so bad. But no worries, because Osborne is promising a Budget on 23 March that will be "unashamedly pro-growth, pro-enterprise and pro-aspiration". Perhaps. More likely is that it will be too little too late.

The Chancellor has hinted that he will help motorists by reversing plans for a rise in fuel duty of 1p above the rate of inflation. I recall, in January, the chief secretary to the Treasury, Danny Alexander, denying this would happen. Another coalition U-turn.

Repeat offenders

Enter Mervyn King, who used a newspaper interview directly to contradict Osborne's claim that the recession was all Labour's fault. He argued sensibly that, instead, the blame lay with the banks and the financial sector. Given that Osborne has touted the governor of the Bank of England as the font of all economic knowledge since King backed the coalition's austerity measures last year, this was an embarrassing intervention for him, to say the least.

My old pal didn't stop there. "Why do banks in general want to pay bonuses?" he asked. “It's because they live in a 'too big to fail' world in which the state will bail them out on the downside."
His assertion that "you need a credible plan to reduce [the deficit] over the lifetime of a parliament" is hardly a ringing endorsement of Osborne's claim that his is the only way to tackle the crisis. King was asked whether there could be a repeat of the financial crisis. "Yes," he replied. "The problem is still there. The search for yields goes on. Imbalances are beginning to grow again."

Any repeat of the crisis would plunge the economy back into recession at a time when Osborne had taken it to its knees. No wonder the governor is voting against rises in interest rates. This is a major blow to the government's claim that all is well and that the economy can withstand the austerity cuts and tax increases. Perhaps most important of all, King stated that the action taken to address the financial crisis, in 2008 and 2009, "prevented a repetition of the Great Depression".

That is the correct assessment, and the Federal Reserve chairman, Ben Bernanke, holds an identical view. Osborne and Cameron opposed those measures, so why should we trust them now? Mervyn certainly doesn't seem to.

David Blanchflower is NS economics editor and a professor at Dartmouth College, New Hampshire, and the University of Stirling.

Tuesday, 8 March 2011

Mervyn King tried to halt the financial crisis...

...six months before it happened.

As we reported last week, Bank of England boss Mervyn King is categorical in stating that the current round of austerity cuts are entirely to blame on the bankers and not the national defecit. Read here.

Not only that. Mervyn is revealed in Wikileaks to have been trying to galvanise internatuional action to help prevent the financial collapse.

In a March 2008 cable leaked by WikiLeaks to the Guardian, Bank Governor Mervyn King told U.S. ambassador in London Robert Tuttle that British banks needed injections of capital and that central bankers should coordinate their efforts.
"It could be a temporary group and (King) suggested that perhaps the central banks and finance ministers of the U.S., the UK and Switzerland could coordinate discussions with other countries that have large pools of capital, including sovereign wealth funds, about recycling dollars to recapitalise banks," Ambassador Tuttle said in the confidential memo.
"He said it is hard to look at the big four UK banks (Royal Bank of Scotland, Barclays, HSBC, and Lloyds TSB) and not think they need more capital. A coordinated effort among central banks and finance ministers may be needed to develop a plan to recapitalize the banking system," the cable to Washington added.


By October 2008, U.S. investment bank Lehman Brothers had collapsed and Lloyds, Royal Bank of Scotland and HBOS had all been rescued by the government. According to the cable, King told the U.S. ambassador and former U.S. Treasury Deputy Secretary Robert Kimitt, who was visiting London, that the Group of Seven major economies was no longer relevant to deal with global financial issues. "The G7 is almost dysfunctional on an economic level, said King. Key economies are not included, especially those that have large and growing pools of capital. King said that a new international group was needed to address the issue," Tuttle said in the cable.
King also said, according to the cable on the Guardian's website, it was imperative to find a way for banks to sell off unwanted illiquid securities, including mortgage backed securities, without resorting to sales at distressed valuations.


"The King proposals were not casual ideas developed in the course of luncheon conversation. It was clear that his principal objective in the meeting was to outline his outside-the-box thinking for Kimmitt," the cable said.

Monday, 7 March 2011

Calamity Hague

First he saved expenses by sharing a hotel room with an asistant.

Then he told us Colonel Gadaffi was on a plane bound for Venezuela.

Then he couldn't manage the evacuation of the Britons stranded there.

Then he authorised an excursion into the Libyan desert that led to 8 Britons, including SAS forces, heavily armed but travelling under false passports being apprehended by Libyan farmers.

Then he tells us he gives his full support to the Duke of York.

And now reckons we can impose a 'no fly zone' over Libya?

.... good luck with that 'Billy Boy'!

'Call Me'... Stupid? Cameron steps into the deep end.

"We are the party of enterprise" said David Cameron in his Cardiff speech.

He then went on... "So I can announce today that we are taking on the enemies of enterprise.The bureaucrats in government departments who concoct those ridiculous rules and regulations that make life impossible, particularly for small firms.The town hall officials who take forever with those planning decisions that can be make or break for a business - and the investment and jobs that go with it.The public sector procurement managers who think that the answer to everything is a big contract with a big business and who shut out millions of Britain's small and medium sized companies from a massive potential market."

We think 'Call Me Dave' is foorgetting a few things.

Firstly, the financial crisis was caused by failures in the private sector that the public sector had to rescue. RBS and Lloyds were moved from the private sector and are now in the public sector.

Secondly, the spending cuts which reduce local authority budgets are probably going to increase the amount of time that it takes to deal with a planning application. Additionally for these local authorities faced with spending cuts, it makes sense for the procurement officer to try to buy the goods as cheaply as possible which will often mean in bulk from one large, single supplier.

Thirdly, there are not millions of small to medium sized companies being squeezed out by bureaucracy. According to the Department of Business Innovation and Skills estimates for 2009, there were only 1.2 million enterprises with any employees at all in total in the UK. So that claim simply is not true.

Oh yeah, and despite lending the British banking sector trillions of pounds in subsidised money that we pay the interest on (we are borrowing internationally at 3.6% and lending to the 'banks' at 0.5%) these very same banks pointedly refuse to invest in the very same small businesses that 'Call Me Dave' claims to support. That is the lack of investment and hence jobs that he bemoans. Yet he allows the very same bankers complete freedom to pay massive bonuses paid for out of taxpayers money, and engineers financial deregulation in the background to allow even more abuses of our finances.

Even a die hard Tory must be shaking their head in disbelief at this master of the inane and just plain wrong and stupid.

Mervyn King is right - we are being exploited by the banks

While the bankers seethe at Mervyn King’s remarks suggesting that they routinely rip off their customers, their clients, from the humblest current account customer to FTSE 100 chief executives, will heartily agree.

The government would do well to ignore the bankers’ wrath.

What more are average overdraft rates of 18% at a time when the base interest rate stands at an all time low of 0.5% than a blatant rip off?

The depressing thing about it all is that there is nothing new about any of this – just the scale of the rip off which is as bad as it has ever been. If the Financial Services Authority, not exactly a Doberman as watch dogs go, feels it necessary to warn wealthy bank clients that they are likely to be targeted for dubious ‘wealth management services’ then banks must have stooped to new lows.

Read More here.

And here.

Friday, 4 March 2011

LibDems consigned to 6th place in Barnsley

The utter collapse of the LibDem vote in Barnsley might be a significant sign of public anger at the ConDem's wayward governance.

Mervyn King, the governor of the Bank of England, says he is 'surprised that the degree of public anger has not been greater than it has'

So are we...

We are suprised that Lansley hasn't been mugged for even suggesting some of the changes he plans to implement in the NHS.

We were surprised that Clegg wasn't lynched for his support of university fee increases.

Suprised Hunt hasn't been kicked from pillar to post for approving Murdoch's takeover of BSkyB.

..and yes, surprised that the British public fell for the ConDem lie that Labour were at fault for the bank-led financial crisis.

So, the bankers have made their bonuses, Rupert is firmly in control of all the levers of power, the NHS is openly being privatised and the university sector is shortly to follow. Merv has a right to be surprised. We are apoplectic !!!

Thursday, 3 March 2011

Voluntary Early Release Scheme

We are not able to advise individuals on personal choice and decisions in relation to applying for the VERS. General advice would be that if you apply it must be because you are genuinely prepared to accept the terms currently on offer.

However, our solicitors have provided the following wording for individuals to use when accepting an offer. In the event that the terms of the scheme are successfully challenged through the courts, this might provide members affected with some route to recourse action.



Acceptance of VERS payment

I am accepting the redundancy and other payments made to me without prejudice to my right to claim that the changes to the Civil Service Compensation Scheme laid before Parliament on 21 December 2010 have not been lawfully made, and that I am entitled to payments in accordance with the terms of the Civil Service Compensation Scheme as it applied before those changes were purportedly made.

Signed
Dated

The Tories’ shameful attack on trade unionism

The decision to end funding for the International Labour Organisation is a betrayal of Arab workers.

Why does this government hate workers so much? Yesterday, two of the richest men in European politics, the former Lazard banker Andrew Mitchell and the former oil trader Alan Duncan, sat side by side on the Commons front bench smirking with self-satisfaction as they announced a major assault on democratic trade unionism.

Tucked away at the end of a rambling statement about changes in Britain's overseas aid budget was a bombshell. The two millionaires said the UK would cut support to the International Labour Organisation. Britain will stay an ILO member, but the consistent cross-party financial support for the organisation's work has now been terminated.

The ILO cut is incoherent in Whitehall terms. In his speech in Kuwait and again in his statement in the Commons on Monday, David Cameron said he supported free association as a core right that Arabs rising in revolt against authoritarian rulers should enjoy. Freedom of association is at the very centre of ILO philosophy. The Mitchell-Duncan cuts seem, therefore, to contradict what Cameron called for – unless, of course, the Prime Minister did not understand what he was saying. (And of course he has form in that regards.)

Read more here.

New MoD cuts could mean even more troops face the sack

New defence cuts will be made in the coming weeks, ministers have signalled, raising fears of more redundancies in the Armed Forces.

Dr Liam Fox, the Defence Secretary, was criticised on Wednesday for announcing that troops now in Afghanistan could be among 11,000 personnel who will be sacked to save money.
After being summoned to the Commons to explain the redundancies, Dr Fox conceded that he may have to make more cuts as he struggles to balance the Ministry of Defence budget.

Defence sources said the department’s planning for 2011-12 had identified a significant gap between the MoD’s financial commitments and its allocated budget. That could lead to equipment being cut, with potential implications for Armed Forces personnel.

Read more here.

Wednesday, 2 March 2011

Bank of England governor blames spending cuts on bank bailouts

Mervyn King tells MPs: 'The price of this financial crisis is being borne by people who absolutely did not cause it'

Mervyn King has risked reopening the bitter argument over blame for the financial crisis by saying that government spending cuts are the fault of the City and expressing surprise there has not been more public anger.

The governor of the Bank of England said that people made unemployed and businesses bankrupted during the crisis had every reason to be resentful and voice their protest. He told the Treasury select committee that the billions spent bailing out the banks and the need for public spending cuts were the fault of the financial services sector.

"The price of this financial crisis is being borne by people who absolutely did not cause it," he said. "Now is the period when the cost is being paid, I'm surprised that the degree of public anger has not been greater than it has."

King has repeatedly pointed the finger at the City since the crisis erupted in 2007, but this was the first time he blamed bankers for the coalition's spending cuts.

So it wasn't the defecit, as we have been saying all along. The banks should be paying instead of profiting from the financial crisis. But while public services burn the 'Boy' George Osborne fiddles... and allows the banks to gorge themselves at our expense.

Read more here.

Tuesday, 1 March 2011

National Minimum Wage

A surprise not perhaps, that the ConDems are seeking to ammend the National Minimum Wage.

"The Low Pay Commission must consider and take evidence on the availability of employment opportunities and the impact of the national minimum wage on job creation and access to employment in all travel to work areas where the average level of unemployment in the preceding year has been above the national average, and must consider in the light of that assessment whether to recommend that the minimum wage in any such area should be set at a level below the national minimum wage."

Read the bill here

PCS response to MoD voluntary early release scheme (VERS) 2011/12 proposals


Introduction 1. This response to the department's proposed voluntary early release scheme is without prejudice to our opposition to the proposed 25,000 civilian job losses within the Ministry of Defence (MOD) and our opposition to the imposed new terms for the Civil Service Compensation Scheme (CSCS), which will be the subject of further legal challenge by PCS nationally. It therefore should not be seen as acceptance either of the proposed reductions or of use of the imposed CSCS terms and definitions.

2. PCS rejects the need for 25,000 civilian jobs to be cut from the MOD. We have proposed clear alternatives to deficit reduction, including closing the £120Billion tax gap and have alternative proposals within the MOD to make significant savings in operating costs without the need to cut civilian jobs, including civilianisation, ending outsourcing and privatisation and the removal of consultants, contractors and agency staff.
We have been seeking to progress these with the department under the Managing Surpluses Agreement (MSS), so far without success. We will also be raising these with the Secretary of State at our long delayed meeting on 28 February and will be campaigning against cuts in jobs and services.

3. PCS does not accept that compulsory redundancies are necessary and will seek the full and proper application of the Cabinet Office protocols for handling surplus staff situations, alongside the Managing Surpluses Agreement in any rundown within the MOD. PCS therefore objects to management’s refusal to engage with the trade unions, as laid down in the MSS agreement, to jointly agree measures to address any potential surplus within the MOD.

4. PCS does not accept that the new compensation scheme is lawful and therefore will not agree to its terms, nor to their being applied in a compulsory redundancy situation.

5. PCS will argue for discretion to be used to make available the best possible scheme terms and will consider advising members not to apply for the VERS at this time.

6. We deplore that fact that, once again, this proposal has not been subject to an equality and diversity impact assessment as required by both departmental policy and legislation before consultation. There is therefore no reference to how the department intends to safeguard the interests of protected groups under the Equality Act, nor how they will ensure that the selection criteria outlined does not discriminate against protected groups.

7. We hope that this consultation response will see the start of a meaningful dialogue with the trade unions, under the auspices of the Managing Surpluses Agreement, on dealing with the potential surplus situation within the MOD and delivering a fit for purpose voluntary early release scheme as part of a range of measures to mitigate against compulsory redundancies. The suggestion that the VERS will launch on 28 February, with applications concluded by 31 March, does not fit with this aspiration and we hope that the department, and if not the department then the Secretary of State, is willing to accept that achieving an agreement on this issue is worth further time and consideration.

General comments

8. In a department that attaches so much importance to the need to plan, the absence of any information on the prospects for staff and their careers; what skills are needed and, more importantly where (given the extent of family commitments nowadays) is appalling. Further the lack of any information for future years leaves staff in an invidious position because they do not have the information that they need to be able to make a decision.

9. The main problem with the scheme is that it perpetuates the problem with the previous schemes in that although many grades/skills are found across the MOD, it will be up to TLBs who agree to release. Too little importance is attached to location, especially as the releases for a particular site which has several TLBs will not be considered alongside each other. One could find that a TLB that is changing its skill requirement could be releasing a particular skill which is in short supply in another TLB.

10. No evidence has been supplied to back up either the assumption that natural wastage and restrictions on external recruitment will ‘deliver’ 4,500 reductions, nor to justify the proposed spread of releases over the three year period. It is also not clear whether all TLBs are expected to contribute proportionately to the reductions targets.

11. Whilst PCS accepts that some refreshment, by external recruitment, may be necessary over the coming period we would wish to see greater control exercised in determining whether posts could be filled by existing staff through retraining or by surplus staff from other government departments through CSVacs.

12. The document talks about the use of MODOPS and planning for retirement courses. We know that these have been overwhelmed by the level of demand and impacted by the department’s travel and subsistence cuts. What guarantees have we that these services will be adequately resourced to deal with the increased level of need; available when people need them and in the locations that people need to access them?

13. We would seek specific assurances that staff on career breaks, long term sickness absence, loans to other government departments, secondments, homeworkers and others covered by the requirements of the Keeping in Touch scheme will be notified of the VERS and have all the information available to them to participate on the same basis as those within the department.

14. We need further details about the team to be set up to manage this process: how many posts, over what timeframe, what knowledge and experience.

15. The department has to ensure, in all its communications, that staff in the redeployment pool do not believe that their only option is to apply for the VERS.

Eligibility

16. Despite in the aftermath of the SDSR announcement suggesting that reductions would be managed with the aid of a departmental early release scheme, this is clearly neither covers all staff in the department nor is managed departmentally with common selection criteria. The result is likely to be that once again the department loses key skills in one area that it has to recruit in another, wasting taxpayers’ money on both redundancy and recruitment costs.17. It is not clear whether all civilian staff are eligible to apply for the scheme, e.g. those on long term sick, those who are suspended, those on inefficiency warnings (Para 14 partially refers to performance).

Terms

18. It is disappointing that the department has not sought to talk to the trade unions about variations to the standard tariff for what is, in the first year at least, a voluntary exit scheme. For example, offering two months pay for every year of service up to the first five years, might make the scheme more attractive to those with limited service, as would waiving the two year qualification period.

19. Clarification is sought that the terms on offer for all the proposed schemes (SCS, USVF, RAF bases, etc.) will be the same. The department already proposes to run a two tier scheme, with military staff working alongside civilians leaving on significantly more generous terms. It is important therefore that the terms on offer for all civil servants are the same.

20. Clarification is also sought that the restrictions on payments to those above ‘normal pension age’ are not discriminatory on grounds of age.

21. There remains huge confusion over whether the proposal is for a voluntary exit scheme or a voluntary release scheme and whether this is a pre redundancy or redundancy avoidance measure. The department must be clear with staff that applications under this first phase will have no effect either on later stages or on possible selection for compulsory redundancy should the department get to the point of declaring compulsory redundancies.

22. PCS believes that as this current proposal is for a voluntary exit scheme, there will be restrictions on staff both applying for unemployment or jobseekers allowance (or the new universal credit when it is introduced) and for payment of mortgage protection insurance. If the department believes otherwise, then they have to demonstrate to all staff how their entitlements to benefits will not be affected by agreeing to a voluntary early exit under this current scheme and guarantee that the Department for work and Pensions will not reject any applications for benefits arising from such a voluntary ending of employment.

Estimates

23. We do not accept that staff should be asked to make life changing decisions, armed only with information secured from the ‘my CSP’ online calculator. As a minimum, comprehensive guidance should be available particularly around qualifying and continuous service and how salaries are quantified to calculate compensation and pension outcomes. We would also encourage the department to set up a helpline within PPPA and to make available access to financial advice.

24. We also question why the department recognises that some staff will not have access to a computer and is therefore providing an offline, paper based application service through PPPA but then expects those same staff to obtain compensation and pensions estimates online!

Application process

25. The window for applications is too short, particularly when individuals will be deciding whether to apply with no qualitative information on what is happening to their post, their business unit, their site or their profession. This is likely therefore to encourage speculative applications, which will either be withdrawn as the process moves forward and further information becomes clear, or will lead to the individuals turning down offers of early release at the end of the process. This will have involved significant nugatory processing effort and raises at least the possibility that the department will not reach its targets and that individuals who wanted to go have been denied that opportunity.
Selection process

26. PCS fundamentally rejects the use of performance, in any form, as a selection criterion (or as any form of ‘check’ against decision making) for the VERS. The subjective nature of performance markings and bonus awards is well known, as is the potential to discriminate against groups protected under the Equality act. To utilise this subjective information for selection for early release would be open to challenge. We also question the legality of releasing performance award information to selection panels, as this may have data protection implications as it goes against the purpose for which the information was originally collected and held by the department.

27. Clarification is needed on other factors which may be taken into account. Recruitment and retention allowances and market skills supplements (if any are currently in payment) should not automatically disbar recipients from early release. These allowances are reviewable and renewable and a review of continued applicability should be made before using their payment as a means of ruling out applicants for early release. Clarity is also needed on professional training – what happens to someone who is part way through such training, or who did not qualify?

28. Lessons have clearly not been learned from the 2008 early release scheme, where selection by TLB stovepipe (with TLBs also allowed to determine their own selection criteria and weightings) led to alarmingly varied outcomes. In particular, many TLBs managed to let staff go on ERS whose skills they desperately needed, so ended up bringing back those same individuals as contractors or agency staff on massively inflated day rates.

29. There is a worrying lack of clarity over the role of independent members in selection panels and also the potential for conflicts of interest if managers in the line management chain make up selection panels. Will all selection panels have mandatory criteria and how will compliance be audited?

30. It is clear that some skills champions, such as in the finance area as recently notified to the trade unions, have been unable to develop skills profiles and requirements for their specialisms. What confidence can we therefore have that Annex A represents anything other than a back of an envelope assessment?

31. In addition, Annex A makes no reference to the relevance and currency of certain skills, i.e. when the qualification was obtained, what continuous professional development and refreshment has been undertaken, is the skill still used by the individual and the department on a regular basis, can the individual be redeployed to areas which have shortages.

32. Annex A is also predominantly weighted towards higher grades. Does this suggest that the department has little further need for support and admin grades, or sees little need to retain them, train or develop them to become the seed corn for the higher grades of the future? Many of the protected groups under the Equality Act are contained in the lower grades and this perceived failure to value them is worrying.

33. Will skills criteria be consistent with those from previous early release schemes, such that people who were rejected in 2008 on the grounds of skills be discouraged from applying again?

34. PCS would like to see some element of ‘knock for knock’ releases, allowing individuals to leave to create opportunities for those in the redeployment pool (or those made surplus from other government departments) to secure permanent posts. Some element of vacancy matching, of skills in the RDP and skills in the TLBs would enable sensible workforce planning and avoid the potential for compulsory redundancies later.

35. It is not clear how the selection criteria in Para 12 are scored or weighted. Are all five points scored equally (i.e. count for 20% of the overall score)? PCS would prefer to see cost used only to determine releases where all other factors are equal, as otherwise cost will negate all the other criteria. If the in year cost of an individual’s release is high, what safeguards are there to avoid that individual being retained when their skills profile and location have minimal prospect of meeting future Departmental needs.

Notification and acceptance

36. Little is said in the consultation document about appeals. Again a lesson that should have been learned from the 2008 ERS exercise is that aggrieved individuals will pursue their grievance to the limit of departmental procedures. Efforts should therefore be made to secure a robust, timely and independent appeals process to demonstrate fairness, including oversight from DCP. Staff should have access to all material used by the selection panel to reach their decision, including weighted scores and skills assessments.

37. Greater clarity is needed about how individuals will be notified of the result of their application. Will this be via PPPA direct or through their line manager and will there be a common result date? How will individuals outside of the department (i.e. on the keeping in touch scheme) be notified?

38. We believe that individuals should be able to choose their departure date to best suit their financial circumstances and that payment of compensation in lieu of notice should be available as a default option. This would at least have the advantage of making for most people an unattractive package slightly more attractive. Individuals should also be able to minimise any tax implications by choosing a departure date which mitigates against their compensation payment taking them into a higher tax bracket.

Further consultation

39. The CD makes clear that there will be further consultation on future phases of the VERS proposal, on the development of frequently asked questions and guidance relating to the VERS and on proposals relating to specific sites and locations (Kinloss, USVF bases, etc.). We would wish to see such future consultation take place under the auspices of the Managing Staff Surpluses agreement and to be governed by a formal engagement plan with the trade unions.

Monday, 28 February 2011

HSBC bank profits more than doubled in 2010

HSBC today reported profits more than doubled in 2010 to 19 billion US dollars (£11.8 billion), with every region in the black for the first time since 2006.

The banking giant's result marks a sharp rise on the 7.1 billion dollars (£4.4 billion) posted in 2009.

But HSBC's new chairman Douglas Flint said the group will "not forget" the financial crisis and support from governments around the world, adding the group entered 2011 "with humility".
However, they then go on to pay new chief executive Stuart Gulliver - formerly head of the investment bank - a £5.2 million bonus for 2010, taking his total package for the year to £6.2 million.

The bank's former boss Michael Geoghegan - who stepped down as chief executive on December 31 - picked up a £3.8 million bonus and a total package of £5.8 million for the year. He will continue to work for the group until he retires on March 31, and will be paid more than £1.4 million in pay and pension this year. Mr Geoghegan is also entitled to £200,000 for three months' consultancy work after he retires, although he will donate this to charity.

Well, that's alright then.

Friday, 25 February 2011

Stop The Cuts Demo

Saturday 26th February


Blackpool


11:00 am



Corporation Street



See you there.

Mark Serwotka Guest Speaker at our AGM

Mark Serwotka delighted members yesterday when he attended the Annual General Meeting as our guest speaker.

He gave an inspiring speech to the well attended meeting and answered numerous questions from members.

The main point of his talk was that we are facing the darkest period that any of us will experience during our working lives. Under the cover of the recession, the government is preparing to dismantle the State whatever the cost to jobs and services.

However, there is hope, and it is planned that all the public sector unions will unite to fight the cuts.

A full report will follow.

America’s Tea Party of the left...

...is a warning to the coalition.

The US trade union rallies are spreading from Wisconsin to Ohio and beyond. Leaders in the UK must realise that their own public sector will not sit idly by as austerity measures kick in.

David Blancflower, The New Statesmen

The new US Super Bowl champions, the Green Bay Packers, got a heroes' welcome when they brought the trophy home to the northern state of Wisconsin in early February. The Packers frequently play in below-zero temperatures (Fahrenheit, that is) on the frozen tundra of Lambeau Field, the stadium named after the team's founder, Curly Lambeau. "Cheesehead" is a nickname, sometimes used disparagingly, for a person from Wisconsin - a nod to the large volume of cheese produced in the area. It is also the nickname of Packer fans, many of whom wear cheesehead hats to home games.


But Wisconsin has been in the news for another reason - namely the angry response of many of its citizens to a fiscal austerity bill intended to deal with the state's $3.6bn budget deficit. Around 70,000 cheeseheads have gathered at the state capitol in Madison to protest against plans by the new Republican governor, Scott Walker, to remove the collective bargaining rights of around 175,000 public-sector employees. Teachers have turned out in such large numbers that some schools have been forced to close due to understaffing. Trade unionists have agreed to double their health insurance contributions and to put 5.8 per cent of their salary towards their pensions, but would not accept the removal of their bargaining rights. Walker insists there is "no room to negotiate".

Read the article in full here.

Soldiers to be trained to run prisons

Soldiers will run prisons if guards go on strike as part of protests against public sector cuts, it was revealed today.

Thousands of troops will receive training in restraint techniques and fire safety as the Government prepares contingencies against a wave of industrial action.

Ministers expect staff to walk out over Justice Secretary Ken Clarke's plans to privatise two prisons and have drawn up plans with the Ministry of Defence, The Times reported.